Yoni: Fighter and Writer By Elli Wohlgelernter (July 3) - Twenty-five years after he fell while commanding the Entebbe raid, Yonatan Netanyahu is still considered an international hero with a universal message. Yoni Netanyahu has been gone 25 years, yet he still lives on. Not only his name, carried by those born after him, and on street signs and schools from Jerusalem to San Antonio, Texas; not only through his inspiring legacy of bravery and heroism; but also through his thoughts and ideas, which stretch back nearly 40 years, yet are so remarkably relevant to Israel's current situation that his exact words are now resounding on the nightly news. Those words, almost quaint in the world of post-Zionism, are part of a renewed interest in Yoni. In addition to last week's commemoration of the silver anniversary of the Entebbe operation, there is also the reissuing of his book of letters, a new documentary on his life that aired Wednesday night on Israel Television, the establishment of a nonprofit organization dedicated to perpetuating his memory, and also the realization that his understanding of Israel's political reality then is as applicable an argument today as when he first wrote it. "As you no doubt know from reading the papers, the situation in Israel is, in a word - catastrophic! Not a day passes, literally, without a border incident, sabotage, mine explosion, murder, ambushes, shootings and setting fire to fields. During all the years of my service and of my living here the situation has never been so tense. In the army, everyone is impatient - when are we finally going to strike back?!! We have complete confidence in our strength. We are capable of anything." - October 25, 1966 Yoni's basic story is that of a 30-year-old reconnaissance unit (Sayeret Matkal) commander who led the successful July 4, 1976, raid on Entebbe that saved the lives of 104 hostages, but which ended tragically with his death. That story alone would have guaranteed his name being added to the pantheon of Jewish war heroes, together with Joseph Trumpeldor, Hanna Szenes and Mickey Marcus. But two subsequent events enlarged the legacy, making Yoni's name publicly known beyond that of any other fallen soldier hero. One was the publication of Michtavei Yoni (The Letters of Jonathan Netanyahu), which revealed the inner thinking and feeling of an extraordinarily mature, sensitive Zionist patriot. The other is the political rise of his younger brother, Binyamin, and the efforts by political opponents to tarnish Yoni in an attempt to damage his sibling. In addition, there are the efforts of the post-Zionists, or anti-Zionists, anxious to discredit any part of Israel's history, including its heroes, from Trumpeldor to David Ben-Gurion to Yoni Netanyahu. Yet the legend remains, in part, because of the effect Entebbe had on so many people, from an American immigrant who named his son after Yoni, to Prisoner-of-Zion Natan Sharansky, who felt, sitting in solitary confinement, that he, too, would be rescued one day. The story of Entebbe has been told many times, in half-a-dozen books and four movies, though not always accurately. On June 27, 1976, an Air France plane with 228 passengers flying from Tel Aviv to Paris was hijacked, after a stopover in Athens, by two Arabs and two Germans and flown to Entebbe, Uganda, 3,200 km from Israel. A week later, at midnight July 3, the first of the four C-130 Hercules transport planes touched down at the airport, and Operation Thunderbolt - later renamed Operation Yonatan - was under way. A black Mercedes rolled off the plane first and rushed towards the old terminal where the hostages were being held, led by the commander, Lt.-Col. Yonatan (Yoni) Netanyahu. After killing two guards, the lead team leaped from the car and ran towards the building. Just as they were about to charge into the hostage room, Yoni was hit, but as per his instructions not to care for the wounded until the hostages were secured, no one stopped to help him. After the hostages were freed, a team of doctors tried to resuscitate him, but to no avail. Yoni was pronounced dead at the airport. "We were in the first plane that landed, with the Mercedes and two Land Rovers," says Amos Goren, who rode in the Mercedes sitting behind Yoni. "From the point we landed until the terrorists in the room with the hostages were eliminated, took about three or four minutes. From the time we opened the initial fire until that was completed... it took maybe a minute." Goren, a bullhorn in his hand, had been running towards the building with Yoni when he lost sight of him. It was Goren who yelled to the hostages in Hebrew and English, "Koolam lishkav! Everybody lie down! We are the Israeli army!" Ten seconds later, the room was secured and the second-in-command, Muki Betzer, received word over the radio that Yoni had been hit. "That's when we knew of it initially," remembers Goren, retelling the story he has told hundreds of times in the past 25 years. "The next we heard of [Yoni's death] was when we landed in Nairobi. We were resting in the plane - I was actually sleeping in the front seat of the Mercedes - and Ehud Barak,who was in the airplane that flew above [Entebbe], joined us there. He came onto the plane, and he was the one who told us. He told me personally as I was sitting in Yoni's seat." Goren had been a last-minute replacement to join the assault team, replacing a soldier who had become ill on the flight to Sharm e-Sheikh. On the back of an airsickness bag, Yoni sketched for him the outline of the terminal and the assault routes, and clarified everybody's task. "While Yoni was explaining all this to me, we were informed that the government had given us the green light to carry on to Entebbe, that we were going to do it," Goren is quoted - in the afterword to the new edition of Yoni's book, written by the youngest Netanyahu brother, Iddo - as saying: "Yet he stayed completely calm... and went on explaining to me my job, as though we were going to perform an exercise." For those who knew Yoni - who had been with him on previous assault operations and who had known him in civilian life - it was hardly surprising. "Yoni didn't have to die to become a legend, because he was already a legend in his own lifetime," says brother Binyamin, known to Yoni and the family, since he was a child, by the nickname Bibi. "Those who knew him knew him as a commander in the army, knew him as an outstanding human being, knew of his many daring exploits, rescuing for example Yossi Ben-Hanan in the Yom Kippur War, or other brave actions, courageous actions that he took and succeeded in." Yoni Netanyahu, born March 13, 1946 - the 11th of Adar and the 26th anniversary of the yahrzeit of Trumpeldor - was a leader from the very beginning, according to Meretz MK Naomi Chazan, a grade-school classmate of Yoni's in what was then called Hadarom School in Jerusalem, today named for Henrietta Szold. "He was definitely one of the leaders of the class," says Chazan, "and very competitive in sports - sports and hamesh avanim [the Israeli version of jacks], that's what we used to play. And soccer. We were buddies, we were friends, a whole bunch of us sort of hung out together. He definitely stood out, because he was good at what he did." Iddo also remembers Yoni as a leader, playing in their Jerusalem neighborhood of Katamon, "even with kids who were older than he. He was not a bully, however. Never. Although he did beat up kids who were thugs - he had no fear. He was also an outstanding athlete, a very, very good soccer player and runner. In high school in America, at Cheltenham High School [in Philadelphia], he was captain of the team. The coach said years later that Yoni could have been a professional soccer player. "There was no question he was a leader, you could sense it... But you could sense beyond that something else, something that really made him a remarkable person, beyond just being a leader. It's reflected in many ways in his letters." It is during his year and a half at Cheltenham High that the letters of Yoni Netanyahu begin. It is striking how mature and thoughtful he was even at the age of 17, a clear harbinger of what lay ahead. "But man does not live forever, and he should put the days of his life to the best possible use. He should try to live life to its fullest. How to do this I can't tell you. If I had a clear answer, I'd have half the solution to the puzzle called life. I only know that I don't want to reach a certain age, look around me and suddenly discover that I've created nothing, that I'm like all the other human beings who dash about like so many insects, back and forth, never accomplishing anything, endlessly repeating the routine of their existence only to descend to their graves, leaving behind them progeny that will merely repeat the same 'nothingness.'" - May 23, 1963 He disliked being in America, where he had moved at age 17 with his family to enable his father to pursue his research in Jewish history. He longed to be back with his friends in Israel. But it made no difference in his studies, where he placed first in his class in math and history, and did well in other subjects while only spending, as he put it: "a sixth of the time studying that the average student does here." Upon graduation, Yoni left his parents, Benzion and Cela, and his brothers - Bibi, three years younger, and Iddo, six years younger - and returned to Israel to enlist in the army, volunteering for the toughest course, the paratroopers. The letter-writing continued, in snatches of time between drills, as he kept his family abreast of his development first as a superior soldier and thereafter as an outstanding officer. "Tonight I'm returning to the base. They say that from Wednesday to Saturday we'll have a march to 'get to know your personal equipment,' which means marching 25 miles a day. But that doesn't worry me. I've reached the conclusion that anything the army requires of a soldier, I can do." - September 8, 1964, - a few days into basic training Those earnest sentiments sound almost old-fashioned today, but they were, in fact, the very fiber around which Yoni's character was structured, according to his brothers. Not only was Yoni mature, says Bibi, "but he also subordinated his life to his ideals. Most people have convictions and ideals which they sort of keep in a drawer, and occasionally refer to them, but they don't really guide their actions on a day-to-day basis. In the case of Yoni, this was different. His ideals were paramount and guided the course of his life. "He understood the importance of defending Israel against those who would snuff out its life. He also understood the personal imperative that commanded him to offer his talent, and, at the end of the day, offer his life, to that great defense." "Since I am in the army and obliged to serve, I'm especially glad I chose the paratroopers. For if you want to extract all that is useful from the service in the way that seems right to me, you have to follow the most difficult road. And this is without a doubt the most difficult." - March 26, 1965 According to Iddo, what distinguished Yoni "was that he had to be one with his actions and with his ideas. He didn't know how to bluff. If he believed, as many did in his age group, that we have to fight for our survival, then he carried these thoughts all the way to the end. This is what characterized him - that there was no dichotomy between his ideas and his actions. And this goes well beyond just going to the army. It carried over to his day-to-day living." Yoni's sense of patriotic purpose was not something he learned solely from his parents, says Iddo. "I really do not recall any atmosphere of indoctrination, whether it was political, or how to live life - it just didn't exist. I would say most of their instruction was by example. There were no sessions where they said: 'Listen, you have to do this,' 'You have to do that,' 'This is important,' 'This is the Zionist ideal' - nothing. But definitely a patriotic sentiment and all that was there. It was part of our being, that's how we grew up. "So from that point of view, I would say yes, obviously he grew up in a Zionist home, a home that was active in the whole idea of the creation of the state. But he was really a self-contained person from the time that I was conscious of him as a child. A whole person unto himself. You could sense even as a child, that he was in many ways elevated. Not that he was haughty or anything like that, but a man who's different." After basic training came Officers' School, a challenge for which Yoni was equally prepared. Towards the end of the course the unit took part in sea maneuver training. "As a result of the wetness most of the soldiers got hard calluses, and the coarseness of our trousers as they rubbed against our bodies caused serious scuff-burns. Some just barely managed to walk, and it was evident that each step was torture. As for me, I enjoyed the whole thing. I suffered no pain or injury." -December 22, 1965 Three weeks later, Yoni was chosen outstanding cadet, and at the graduation ceremony the chief-of-general-staff, Yitzhak Rabin, pinned the insignia on Yoni's uniform. After his discharge a year later, Yoni studied hard for the College Boards. "How do I spend my days? Well, I study mathematics a lot. Sometimes I can sit at the desk without stirring from eleven in the morning to seven at night. I don't even feel the time flitting by." - February 1, 1967 In April of that year, he was accepted to Harvard. Then came the Six Day War, in which Yoni was wounded seriously on the Golan Heights four hours before it was over. He entered Harvard in the fall and did well, getting an "A" in math, "which isn't bad at all for Harvard," he wrote. By year's end he had made the honor list, finishing in the top 10 percent of his class with a near "A" average. But he was not happy there, having been overcome with a feeling of sadness, a "heavy emptiness," as he called it. "The real cause is the sense of helplessness in the face of a war that has no end. For the war has not ended, and it seems to me that it will go on and on. The June war was only one campaign. It's continuing right now, today, yesterday and tomorrow. It continues with every mine and killing and murder, with every explosion in Jerusalem and every shot in the north or the south. This is the 'quiet' before the next storm. I've no doubt that war will come. Nor do I doubt that we will win. But for how long? Until when? We can't wipe out the Arab people; they are too many and have too much support. Of course we shall go on striking them, again and again and again, and we shall be fully justified in delivering a more powerful blow each time. Knowing this makes us feel good, but the good feeling is mingled with sadness. We're young, and we were not born for wars alone. I intend to go on with my studies; I want to do so and I'm interested in doing so. But I can no longer see this as my main mission in life. Even if studying is the right thing - right for me and right for Israel - this isn't the important matter at this time. Deep within my being I'm convinced of this. Hence the sadness I referred to earlier, the sadness of young men destined for endless war. "I wanted you to know what I'm thinking about so that you may know me better, as I should like to know my own son." - August 17, 1968, letter to his parents His decision to leave Harvard and go back to the army was finalized. "In another week I'll be 23. Time flies, doesn't it? My years bear down on me with all their weight. Not as a load or a burden, but as the sum of all the long and short moments that have gone into them. On me, on us, the young men of Israel, rests the duty of keeping our country safe. This is a heavy responsibility, which matures us early. It seems that the young Israeli belongs to a special breed of men. It's hard to explain this, but it can be felt... In another week I'll be 23, and I do not regret what I have done and what I'm about to do. I'm convinced that what I am doing is right. I believe in myself, in my country and in my future. I also believe in my family. That's a great deal for a man my age who has already managed to feel very young and very old." - March 17, 1969 "When he returned from the United States, after spending a year at Harvard, he wanted to rejoin the army, despite the fact that he had a war wound," says Bibi. "And when he looked at where to join the army, he decided to go where I went, which was at the time the cutting-edge of the battle against terrorism." For the remainder of his life he was a professional soldier, participating in numerous military operations, including in Jordan and Lebanon, some of which remain secret to this day. "In this country, at this moment, to be in the army is to be inside - doing, believing, knowing that, after all, my work does bring peace closer or, at least, saves lives and pushes back the threat of war from our gates." - May 3, 1970 One operation he did not take part in was the storming of a hijacked Sabena airplane and the freeing of hostages in 1972. He desperately wanted to, but the unit commander, Ehud Barak, said no, because Bibi was taking part with his team, and the rules said two brothers could not take part in the same operation. "He wasn't too happy, not because I went, but because he couldn't go," recalls Bibi. "He said that he should go, that he's going to join the assault force. I said you can't, because I'm going in there with my own soldiers. He said, well then you stay out. I said I can't: They're my soldiers, I have to lead them. He said then we'll both go. I said that's not a very good idea, because what happens if both of us get killed - what about our parents?" Four years later, it was Yoni's turn to lead a more famous assault operation against terrorism. The maneuver was wildly successful, with only one military fatality: Yoni. From such stories legends are made, and from such operations folklore is fashioned. Couple that with 13 years of what amounts to a personal diary which reveals the delicate feelings of that dead soldier, and you have created a narrative that is larger than life, and a seminal moment in a country's history. "I think that his death at Entebbe marked a unique turning point in the world's battle against terrorism," says Bibi, "because after Entebbe, it was very difficult to argue that you had no choice but to surrender to terrorism." On a personal level, Bibi says, "There's practically not a day that goes by that I don't think of him, and think of what he would do, and this is a great source of spiritual uplifting, but also a great source of sorrow on occasion, when you think of what the country has missed in his death." Following Entebbe, the 27-year-old Bibi established the Jonathan Institute, which was devoted to the task of fighting the source of what took place at Entebbe, terrorism. "His death triggered a great cataclysm in all our lives, the lives of the family, but in the sense of a rededication, in my case it was primarily to advance the battle against terrorism. But I didn't see it then, nor do I see it now, as primarily a military battle of experts or technicians, but more a moral and political battle to at once delegitimize terrorists and expose the cant of their arguments that they are fighting for human rights. And secondly, to expose the governments and regimes that make terrorism possible, without whose active support and direction terrorism collapses. "This is what I wanted to do immediately after Yoni's death. We held several conferences; I published several books, widely read articles that had, according to Secretary of State [George] Shultz, a decisive impact on the United States under President Reagan. It contributed to their adoption of military means and other means - diplomatic and economic sanctions against Libya and other regimes - and this new approach brought an end to the rash of hijackings that had troubled the world. "From this activity, I ended up in diplomacy, and from diplomacy I got into politics. So you might say that Yoni's death triggered the process by which I ultimately ended up in politics, although I didn't have that intention consciously at the time." For Natan Sharansky and all the Jews in the Soviet Union struggling to be free, the raid on Entebbe was an inspiration. For him personally, the raid had added meaning as it took place on the second anniversary of his wedding. When his wife, Avital, called from Israel that day, she held the phone out of the window to let him hear the celebration going on in the street. "When I came to Israel [in 1986], it was the 10th anniversary of Entebbe, and Bibi invited me to speak at the grave. I said that when I was in prison, when I heard the engine of some airplane in Siberia, I immediately was thinking of Entebbe, and it gave me confidence that one day I would be released. Symbolically, I felt the power of Entebbe. It turned into such an important symbol for me and for Jews all over the world, that whatever will happen with you, if you are in trouble, Israel will do everything, and the day will come when the airplane will come and you will be saved. So the image of Israel as a society which is built to be concerned about the saving of Jews, that every Jew who is in danger will be saved by Israel, had a very symbolic and powerful meaning." Yoni himself, Sharansky says, is the individual symbol of that event, "at the same time Superman and at the same time very human and one of us. He became the symbol of this unique role of Israel for us, for Jews, who were fighting for our freedom and for our lives in the Soviet Union. It was almost like an epochal, biblical hero, but at the same time a living person, one of us, and you could be one of them. This immediate connection was very powerful." For Steve Leibowitz, a producer and senior editor at the Israel Broadcasting Authority's English news, the raid on Entebbe was so compelling a moment that he immediately decided to name his first son Yoni. "Entebbe was such an important thing for all of us," says Leibowitz. "I had come on aliya before that, in 1974, and was in the US doing my masters degree when Entebbe happened. I was already involved in Israel emotionally, I was very big supporter of the IDF, and of believing that Israel had to be strong militarily, so when this happened, and there was a victim, to me he was a hero. And I decided at that time - and this was two years before I was married, I didn't even know who my wife would be - that if and when I would have a son, he would be named after Yoni Netanyahu. "I felt that it was more important to me - and I continue to feel that way - that I would rather name my kids after current Zionist heroes than after family members. Yoni will remain with us as a story that is even bigger than the man was. His entire history was a very short history, in terms of his military operations, or his military prowess, or what he was actually involved in. But that story is a story that will live on in a way that the Trumpeldor story lives on. He's a modern-day Trumpeldor." Leibowitz's son Yonatan, 22, says it is "an honor being named after a person who died saving lives. He had a very deep understanding of people. He could very easily find the special unique parts of people he fought with and was friends with. Even though it was the middle of a war, and you don't get a chance to know people, he really made it a point to know everyone around him on a very personal level. "He was very deep, very loving. In the letters that he wrote to his family, you can definitely see that. Everybody should be writing to their family with that much love. Yes, I would say there is some demands that come with the name." In a poll of 500 Israelis released this week by the Association for Commemorating the Memory and Legacy of Lt.-Col Yonatan Netanyahu, a nonprofit organization, 30 percent of the Israeli public did not know what Operation Yonatan was, but 89 percent were familiar with the name Yoni Netanyahu. Of those, 46 percent knew he was the person killed in Entebbe, and only 14 percent knew he was the commander of the rescue force. Most telling of all, of those familiar with the name, 71 percent knew him as Bibi's brother. It is that association that perhaps is the reason why Yoni has fallen from grace in certain circles of left-wing Israeli society. "They have this feeling of reflected glory, that if Bibi rose to the top, he only rose because he was the brother of Yoni," says Iddo. "So if you tarnish Yoni, then you tarnish Bibi. But I wish the attacks on Yoni were only because of that. It's much deeper than that. Because what Yoni represents is Zionism, a willingness to fight, a realistic view of life here, and the idea that if you are not willing to sacrifice your life, you're not going to have a country. And that is the main reason why he was attacked. "For the same reason, they tried to tarnish Trumpeldor, or Hanna Szenes, or other people like that - and Hanna Szenes certainly was on the left, not on the right - but they all represent a kind of thinking that is so alien to the post-Zionist way of thinking, and Yoni, being sort of the last of the line of these great heroes, maybe got more than his share and certainly more than they got, in terms of the attacks on him. "I wish it were only because of politics and the hatred toward Bibi, because that would mean at least things ideologically, if not morally, aren't that bad. Unfortunately, it's much deeper than that." Indeed, Bibi has been accused by critics of using Yoni's name to excess to help further his political career, but the former prime minister dismisses such attacks, saying he has mentioned Yoni's name "very seldom, and not often enough, I think. He's a great example, and I'm very proud of him, and I should mention him a lot more. In fact I don't use his name - this is a very uncommon interview. I've avoided injecting myself personally in any of this, and the number of interviews I've given about Yoni over the years is less than the number of fingers on one hand." Bibi acknowledges that Yoni's name became political fodder, a target for those trying to shoot down his own political career, but that "relatively speaking, there wasn't that much of it, because I think there are natural limits to what one can do and how far one can go, although some people have no limits." That reference might have included former prime minister Ehud Barak. In a stormy Knesset session in June 1997 over the Tze'elim-2 accident, Barak, then opposition leader, was attacked by then-justice minister Tzahi Hanegbi for allegedly fleeing the scene and leaving wounded soldiers behind. When Bibi failed to denounce Hanegbi's attack, Barak rose and said: "I knew another Netanyahu, too, a comrade and a real warrior, and together we rescued wounded soldiers. That was Yoni Netanyahu. I tell you, Bibi, he would have been ashamed of you today." Bibi refuses to discuss the incident. "I think it doesn't even merit a discussion. I dismiss it because, as the British say, 'It's not done.' I can say that it's an abysmal thing." Adds Iddo, "although Bibi didn't express it, there's no question that this hurt him very deeply." Despite how Yoni's name has been misused and abused, he remains for many the hero with a message. "I believe that there is a change in the country now," says Bibi, "and a seeking, an eagerness, to examine our traditional values and the justice of Zionism, and the sacrifices made for Zionism. I think that in that sense there's a natural turn towards Yoni's story." And not just his story, but his message as well, still resonate all these years later. "That's right," says Bibi, "a lot of his prognostications apply to today as though the situation did not change." "What now? I have a definite idea on what ought to be done, but I'm not sure the present government is quite clear about where we're going. The war has finally brought a change of mind to a large section of the public, and this shift in thinking is all to the good. How far it has spread to the nation at large is hard to say, but we'll soon know - elections at the end of December. In any case, I see with sorrow and great anger how a part of the people still clings to hopes of reaching a peaceful settlement with the Arabs. Common sense tells them, too, that the Arabs haven't abandoned their basic aim of destroying the State; but the self-delusion and self-deception that have always plagued the Jews are at work again. It's our great misfortune. They want to believe, so they believe. They want not to see, so they shut their eyes. They want not to learn from thousands of years of history, so they distort it. They want to bring about a sacrifice, and they do indeed. It would be comic, if it wasn't so tragic. What a saddening and irritating lot this Jewish people is!" - November 17, 1973 "The objective facts of our life here - and that's the amazing thing - have not changed one iota since he wrote this," says Iddo. "Nothing has changed. Zero. In terms of a fight for survival, the basic conflict has not gone away. So I think the letters are relevant, as much today as 25 years ago when he died. Because these letters are strong - objectively it's a powerful, powerful document of a certain period, a certain time. That they might be less appealing to some people? Absolutely. Will they always have a hold on some people? No question in my mind, they do. And I don't think that's going to change. What's going to change is how society in general views his ideas." The book, which has never been out of print, is being reissued in the 18th edition in Hebrew, a third edition in English (by Gefen Publishing House), and will be published in Russian in a couple of months. It is part of that growing awareness of Yoni, which includes a new play for young adults called Yoni, a new song called "A letter from Yoni" by Ehud Manor, sung by Rami Kleinstein, and the making of the documentary broadcast for the first time this week. "Even people who are not connected to Judaism, even non-Jews, will find in Yoni a very interesting human being," says Walter Soriano, the documentary's producer. "In a universal way, even to the non-Jews, Yoni is a very strong character, because of his different sides. Through this very strong and very interesting character, he makes you understand how the Jew in him makes him do what he did, coming back from Harvard to go to the army." Soriano doesn't believe in happenstance, and considers that Yoni's death in Entebbe summarized his entire life."Yoni's whole life was saving people, and sacrificing himself for people. That points out what his life was about." "Death - that's the only thing that disturbs me. It doesn't frighten me; it arouses my curiosity. It is a puzzle that I, like many others, have tried to solve without success. I do not fear it because I attribute little value to a life without a purpose. And if I should have to sacrifice my life to attain its goal, I'll do so willingly." - May 23, 1963, age 17